top of page
Search

References and Reputation: What People Say When You Leave the Room

5 days ago
6 min read

Updated: 1 day ago



By the time a client sees your name on a shortlist, three people have already been asked about you. You did not choose them. You will never know who they were. And whatever they said has already shaped the conversation you are about to walk into.


This is not a dark art. It is simply how a small market works. Advertising, media and marketing across Asia is a village, and in a village everyone has worked with everyone, or with someone who has. A headhunter who has been in the market for a decade has, somewhere in their phone, someone who sat next to you in 2014.


Most senior people know this in theory. Almost none of them act on it. They spend weeks on the CV, days on the story, and no time at all on the one thing that decides more shortlists than either: what the market says about them when they are not there.


Move one: the references you give are not the references that matter


Every candidate has a list. Three names, hand-picked, warmed up, ready to say the right things. Clients ask for it at the end, and everyone treats the call as a formality, because it is. A reference you chose is a reference that has already agreed to be kind.


The references that matter are the ones you did not choose. The former boss who was not on your list. The peer who ran the market next to yours. The client who moved to a competitor. The person two levels below you who now runs a department somewhere and is asked, over a drink, what you were really like.


Those conversations happen before the formal references, often before the first interview, and they are the ones a good headhunter trusts. Not because people are unkind, but because people who have nothing to gain are usually honest.


How to: stop thinking of references as a list and start thinking of them as a market. Write down everyone who could be asked about you and would answer, not just the three who would say yes. If the list frightens you, that is useful information, and it is better to have it now than in month three.


Move two: point them to the people before they go looking


If the headhunter is going to ask around anyway, and they are, the question is whether you want to be the one who told them where to look.


Candidates who say nothing about references leave the consultant to find their own. Candidates who offer three hand-picked names from a different industry have told the consultant something too. The candidates who are trusted are the ones who say, in the first meeting, without being asked: "You will know people who have worked with me. The ones I would point you to are these, and I would also understand if you spoke to this person, who I did not get on with, because you will probably hear that anyway."


That does three things. It shows you know how the market works. It shows you are not afraid of what they will hear. And it means that when the difficult name comes up, it comes up as something you raised, not something you hid.


How to: before you meet a headhunter, work out who in their world has worked with you, and lead with those names. Include at least one person who was not a fan. Say why, briefly and without heat, and say what you learned. A reference you have pre-empted is half as damaging as one that arrives as a surprise, and it is often not damaging at all.


Move three: your reputation is already written, and you wrote it


Here is the uncomfortable part.


Your reputation is not the version of you that you describe in interviews. It is the sum of every exit, every restructure, every person you promoted and every person you let go, every client you kept and every one you lost, and above all how you behaved while each of those things was happening.


You did not build it this year. You built it over twenty years, one Tuesday at a time, mostly without noticing. By the time you need it, it is finished. There is no draft to edit.


That is not a reason for despair. It is a reason for honesty. Most people's reputations are better than they fear and more specific than they expect. The market does not remember you as good or bad. It remembers you as the person who did one particular thing well, and possibly one particular thing badly, and it has usually decided which matters more.


And it is worth saying that references are not mostly a negative thing, whatever the word suggests. They are the sum of what you did on ordinary days, and most of that is invisible to you.


For a stretch of my time at WPP, a large part of my job was moving people around the group. I would speak to ten or more candidates a day and pass them on to talent acquisition people in the other operating companies, across markets, without much ceremony. One of them was a woman in Hong Kong whose details I sent to a colleague in Shanghai without telling her, because it seemed the obvious thing to do. She got the role. She knew it was my doing. She did not get round to thanking me until a few years later, and when she did, I had completely forgotten the conversation.


That is how reputation actually works. Not in the grand gestures, but in the Tuesday afternoon you forwarded someone's details because it was the right thing to do, and never thought about again. You will not know most of the time. Occasionally you get the receipt.


How to: ask. Not your friends, who will be kind, and not your enemies, who will not be asked. Ask two or three people in the middle, people who worked with you and have no stake in your next role, one question: "If someone rang you about me, what would you say first?" Listen to the first sentence. That is your reputation. If it matches the story you are telling, you are in good shape. If it does not, you have a choice between changing the story and changing the behaviour, and only one of those works.


Move four: how you leave is the reference that travels


Of all the things that go into a reputation, the one with the longest reach is the exit.


People forget how you arrived. They forget most of what you did. They remember, with surprising precision, how you went. Whether you handed over or disappeared. Whether you thanked people or blamed them. Whether you said anything about the decision, the people who made it, or the direction of the business, to anyone, including the people who agreed with you.


I have watched this from both sides of the table for a long time, and the pattern is consistent. The person who leaves well is talked about well, even by people who were glad to see them go. The person who leaves badly is remembered for the leaving, however good the years before it were. In a market this size, the person you vent to at the farewell drinks is one coffee away from the person who will be asked about you in three months.


How to: if you are still in the building, this is the most important thing in the chapter. Hand over properly, even if nobody asks you to. Thank people individually, in writing. Say nothing about the decision to anyone, however safe it feels. And when you are asked about your old employer in an interview, which you will be, say something true and generous, then move on. It is the single clearest signal of what you will be like on the way out of the next place.


The exercise


Write down the first sentence you think each of these people would say about you if a headhunter rang: your last boss, your best peer, the person you most recently let go, and a client who left.


Then ring one of the middle ones and ask.


The gap between what you wrote and what they said is the work.


Next chapter: networking without begging, or how to use your contacts without spending them.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page