Working With Headhunters: What They Really Assess Over Coffee
Updated: 2 days ago

The best time to meet a headhunter is when you do not need the job.
If the first time a consultant meets you is the month you were let go, you are already behind. They have no read on you. They have no references in hand. You are one of thirty people they met that month, and most of those thirty wanted something.
The candidate who built the relationship two years earlier, comfortably employed and with no reason to, is a different proposition. The consultant already knows how they think. The market has already spoken well of them, unprompted. When the right search lands, that is the person who gets the first call, and the coffee is not an assessment. It is a catch-up between people who trust each other.
Most senior leaders do not do this. They meet headhunters when they need one, and they walk in thinking the coffee is a chat.
It is not a chat. It is the first filter, and most of the shortlist decision is made in it. The consultant asks three questions, gets forty minutes of answers, and leaves with nothing they can present to a client. The candidate leaves feeling it went well.
This chapter is about that hour. Who is really in the room, what they are actually listening for, and eight moves that turn a pleasant coffee into a name on a shortlist. The first move is the one you can start before you ever need it.
Move one: be a source before you are a candidate
A headhunter trades in intelligence. Every time you give them a name, a read on a company, or a heads-up that someone is about to move, you are putting credit in an account you will draw on later.
So meet the two or three consultants who matter in your market while you do not need them. Take the call when they ring about a role that is wrong for you, and give them a name instead. Have the occasional lunch. Be useful.
There is a quieter benefit. A source hears about the market before it is public. Which agencies are restructuring. Which CEOs are wobbling. Which searches are about to open. That is not only useful on the day you need a job. It makes you better at the one you have.
How to: pick the two or three headhunters who actually place people at your level in your market. Once a quarter, send each of them something they can use. A name, an observation, a company you think is about to hire. Never ask for anything. It costs a few hours a year, and it means that when the day comes, you are not starting from zero.
Move two: know what you want before you walk in
The most common thing a headhunter hears over coffee is "I am open to anything." It is said as flexibility. It lands as nothing.
A consultant's job is to match a clear ask to a live search, or to file it accurately for the next one. If you cannot say what you want in a sentence, they cannot sell it in one either, and you have used up a meeting you will want later.
How to: before you go in, write your own brief as one sentence, the way a consultant would say it to a client. "Regional CEO or COO, independent or network, Singapore-based with APAC scope, not interested in pure holding-company roles, floor of X." Say that early and the rest of the hour works.
If you cannot write that sentence yet, do not book the coffee.
A headhunter is not a career coach. If you still need to work out what you want, do that first, with a coach, a trusted peer, or a week of honest thinking, and meet the headhunter when you have an answer. Using a search meeting to think out loud wastes it, and the consultant will remember that you did.
Move three: pick the right headhunter
You are being assessed. You should be assessing too.
A consultant who does not know your market cannot position you, cannot read your references, and cannot tell you what the client actually thinks. Meeting them is a rep, nothing more. In a niche like APAC advertising and media, the list of consultants who genuinely know the players is short, and you probably already know who is on it.
How to: before you accept the coffee, check. Who have they placed in the last two years? Which clients retain them? Do they know the names you would drop? If the answers are thin, be polite, be brief, and save your real preparation for the two or three who are in your world.
Move four: say less
You will want to tell your story. Do not.
The consultant has read your CV. What they need from the hour is to ask their questions, hear precise answers, and watch how you listen. The candidate who talks for forty-five minutes has given them nothing usable and has signalled, loudly, that they will do the same in front of the client.
How to: bring the three things you want them to know about you and say them in the first five minutes. Then let the consultant drive. Answer in two minutes, not twenty. When there is a pause, let it sit. A good headhunter asks precise questions because they are checking specific things. Answer the thing, and stop.
The urge to fill silence is where candidates talk themselves off a shortlist.
Move five: understand who they work for
This is the part nobody tells candidates, and it explains everything else in the chapter.
The headhunter does not work for you. They work for the client who pays the fee. In that transaction you are the product, not the customer. That is not unkind. It is simply where the money flows, and once you see it, the whole meeting makes more sense.
It goes further. A typical consultant spends a third of their week, sometimes more, on business development. Winning the next mandate. So the coffee has a second purpose you cannot see: they are also wondering whether you might be a future client, or know someone who is.
How to: be useful in the room, the same way you were useful before it. Bring a view on the market. Mention a company you think is about to hire. Offer a name that is not your own. A candidate who understands the economics and gives something back moves from being a CV in a drawer to being someone the consultant wants to keep close. That is worth more than any amount of charm.
Move six: point them to your references before they go looking
Years ago I ran a search for a chief executive. The formal references were glowing, as they always are. The informal ones were not. Three people who had worked alongside him, none of whom he had named, each mentioned the same thing without prompting: a personal entanglement that had nothing to do with the job description and everything to do with judgement.
I put it to the client. The client decided it was private and hired him anyway.
Within a year the pattern had repeated, this time on company travel, with itineraries invented to make it work. It became the running joke of the office. Then it became his exit.
The lesson is not about him. It is about how references actually work at senior level. The names you hand over never sink you. The calls you did not know about do, and when three people say the same thing, that is no longer opinion. It is a forecast.
In a market this size, the consultant already has two or three people in their phone who have worked with you. They will ring them before the client ever sees your name. In APAC advertising that is not a risk. It is a certainty.
How to: get ahead of it. Say in the meeting, "You will know people who have worked with me. The ones I would point you to are X and Y." That shows you understand how the market works, and it tells the consultant you are not afraid of what they will hear. The candidate who never mentions references, or who offers three hand-picked names from a different industry, has told them something too.
And the uncomfortable corollary. If there is someone in the market who will speak badly of you, the headhunter will find them. Name it first, briefly and without drama, rather than let it arrive as a surprise.
Move seven: be upfront about money, and know what you are worth
The consultant will ask about money early, sometimes in the first ten minutes. They are not being crude. They are checking whether to continue.
Most candidates anchor on their last package. After a retrenchment that number often feels like something to defend or recover. It is the wrong anchor. What matters is what the role you want pays in this market, and whether you will take it. Your value is what the market will pay for you now, not what you were last paid.
How to: before the coffee, know the market rate for the roles you are targeting. If you were on a holding-company package and are moving to an independent, the number will be lower, and you need to have made peace with that before the meeting, not during it. If you were underpaid, say so plainly, with the market figure. Then give a range and a floor.
Vagueness on money, or a number that is obviously your old package plus ten percent, makes you hard to present and easy to drop. Being upfront is not naive. It is efficient, and the consultant will trust you more for it.
Move eight: be easy to present, then stay on the radar
Every consultant has a moment, usually the evening after the coffee, where they write two paragraphs about you for a client. If those two paragraphs are hard to write, you are not going forward.
How to: make them easy. A clean story of the last ten years in four sentences. A clear reason for the move. A reference list they can call tomorrow. A number that fits the role. No surprises waiting in the market. The candidate who hands the consultant all of that in one hour gets presented, even over someone more impressive who left them with homework.
Then the follow-up, which most people either skip or overdo. Send one short note the same day: thank them, confirm the one-sentence brief, name the references. After that, leave them alone. Every six to eight weeks, send something useful, the way a source would. A market observation. A congratulation on a placement you saw. A name they might want. Never "any updates?"
When you land, tell them before it is announced. When you hear of a search, pass it on. Consultants remember who sent them a mandate for a very long time.
The exercise
Write your one-sentence brief, the way a headhunter would say it to a client. Level, type of business, markets, what you will not do, the floor on money.
Read it to someone who knows the market. If they can repeat it back without asking a question, it is ready. If they cannot, it is not, and neither are you.
Then open your phone and find the two headhunters you should have had lunch with last year. Book it. You do not need the job yet. That is the point.
Next chapter: your story, or how to turn twenty years into two minutes.





Comments